Book Review – “When She Was Good”

by Michael Robotham

I was given an advance review copy of this book by Netgalley.com in exchange for a fair review.

After reading “Good Girl, Bad Girl” I was sure we’d be seeing more of Cyrus and Evie, and I was looking forward to unwrapping the mystery of who Evie is and how she came to be in the situation described in the first novel. After reading “When She Was Good” I’m looking forward to more stories about Evie because she deserves them on her own merits as a character.

Given the subject matter of the crimes described in this book–including family destruction and paedophile sex trafficking–this novel could have been a lurid mess. I’m glad to say that Robotham deftly manages to convey the seriousness and lasting impact of these crimes without dwelling on them in a crass way. I was also impressed that some of the people responsible for these crimes or who enabled them were portrayed as more than 2-dimensional monsters to safely be hated and reviled.

Conversely, the protagonists are flawed people who sometiems act badly or make relatable mistakes. There are no paragons of virtue here, jsut realistic people trying to do the best they can.

I’m not sure that Robotham has quite found a unique voice for Cyrus, yet. Most of his defining characteristics are external–like his tattoos–rather than represented through his dialogue or inner monologue. I also feel like he’s portrayed quite differently in his own two novels than he was when he appeared in “The Secrets She Keeps”–perhaps that’s due to Joe O’Laughlin being an unreliable narrator in that novel?

Evie is very much her own character, and I find her voice much more interesting than Cyrus’s. In a future novel it would be interesting to see her take the role of primary character with Cyrus in a supporting role.

To wrap up, “When She Was Good” is an engaging page-turner with fascinating characters and an interesting story. If you’ve enjoyed Robotham’s novels in the past you’re sure to enjoy this too–but be aware that this novel goes to some pretty bleak places.

If you haven’t read “Good Girl, Bad Girl”, please read that first. You’ll enjoy this book much more as a result.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s